quarterly meeting

March 12, 2024 MPFC Quarterly Meeting

Michigan Prescribed Fire Council Quarterly Meeting

Date: March 12, 2024

Online

 

Attendance:

Stephanie Diep (Kalamazoo Nature Center)

Jack McGowan-Stinski (Lake States Fire Science Consortium)

Julie Mclaughlin (DNR-Contractor)

Ben Savoie (District Forester)

Andy Henriksen (FPAC-NRCS, MI)

Dr. Greg Corace (Alpena Montmorency Conservation District)

Jarod Reibel (Ed Lowe)

Nathan Jeruzal (NWS Grand Rapids)

Frye, Amy (FPAC-NRCS, MI)

Jeb Barzen (WI PFC)

Laura Judge (FPAC-NRCS, MI)

Michele Richards (DMVA)

Mark Sargent

Steve Woods (Huron Pines)

Darwin Schultz

Vic Bogosian

Todd Aschenbach (GVSU)

Tina Stephens (Ann Arbor NAP)

 

Policy Governance: By-Laws Article I: Objectives

Outlined in MPFC’s new strategic plan, each quarterly meeting will include reviewing a portion of the bylaws and revising as necessary, with any proposed changes being voted on during the following meeting.

Discussion was had debating whether or not objectives belong in a set of by-laws. By-laws are how we conduct business, where as strategic plan outlines our goals and how we plan to get there. It was determined that the proposed changes would include changing the objectives outlined in the by-laws to reflect the updated objectives outlined in the strategic plan, and to have article I serve as a bridge to the strategic plan and retitling article I to “objectives, goals, and strategies”, while removing the redundant objectives prior to the by-laws. Jarod R. will craft an edited Article I, and an official vote for adoption of changes will take place during the next quarterly meeting.

Photo of social hour at Burning Issues 2024 located at Fort Custer Training Center, Augusta, MI.

Burning Issues Recap
Burning Issues planning team members reflected on event, detailing how they viewed it as a success, noting good attendance both in-person and virtual, with less virtual hiccups than the year prior, and overall positive feedback from attendees. The event wouldn’t be possible without all of the great speakers donating their time and knowledge. It was great to have Lake States and Tall Grass Prairie Fire Science Consortiums involved again and this year’s involvement was a healthier role with less logistical responsibilities.

During the financial update, Stephanie noted this was the most successful event from a profit standpoint so far, more than double the past two years, even with 40% of registrants receiving some kind of promo for waived or reduced registration cost. The greater profit was mainly a result less billed admin time, and lower admin rates contributing to the profit margin. Planning committee provided a lot of extra logistical support to reduce the amount put on the admin position.

Jeb Barzen, noted WI PFC began working with universities to host annual meeting conferences, noting discounting rentals, essentially offset by the university sponsoring student attendance.

This year’s Burning Issues was one of the more profitable events in the past few years as considerable amount of time was saved from administrative time by dedicated volunteers to help with logistics and the admin rate being reduced to 50% previous year’s rates. Sponsorships came in about the same as last year with a few returning sponsors and a few new. Merchandise sales were as expected. Despite offering 40% of participants free or discounted tickets, ticket revenue was still good.

 

Financial Update Quarter 2

Total Income is at $13,733.44 of the budgeted $42,220.00 annual income. Burning Issues sponsors came in lower than expected but we made good revenue off ticket sales and as expected on merchandise sales.

We have spent $7,411.51 of the $37,720.00 annual budget. Highest expenses are for administrative time (though this is now at a discounted half rate compared to last year), burning issues expense, and restocking merchandise (more t-shirts, pens, and stickers).

 

Subcommittee Updates

Outreach: Tina Stephens

Tina Stephens has taken over as the head of the outreach subcommittee. Meeting next week, and anyone interested in joining is encouraged to contact Tina. Will be determining what the committee wants to do and has the capacity for. A lot of the focus will be put towards the Mi Forest to Mi Faucet grant and determining how we partner with organizations. Several organizations have already expressed interest in hosting learn and burns, being able to cover most of the planning, and mainly would need some expenses covered, along with supplies and volunteer time.

 

Training and Qualifications: Steve Woods
Prescribed fire training exchange (TREX) taking place May 5th to 15th. The course has been filled with 35 people and getting RSVP's from students, 25 or more being FFT2’s, several never having burnt before.

Huron Pines in collaboration with the fire council has been working to establish the Northern Michigan Prescribed Fire Collaborative and trying to get the northern lower NGO’s together and elevate fire literacy and training. MOU for that is circulating currently, with next steps being to develop a mobile fire cache. First fire field day planned for May 30th at Chippewa Nature Center.


The other big initiative of the training and Qualification subcommittee is the training and qualifications MOU which will facilitate participating in training and qualifications activities, including prescribed fire for the purpose of people gaining additional qualifications. Will be sent out to partners at the end of the week. We would also like to have as many of our prescribed Fire Council member organizations, as possible, sign the document.


Nonprofit Collaborator Discussion

We’ve previously discussed becoming a nonprofit, with the primary advantage of not going nonprofit being better involvement from the agencies, but one consequence is the inability to apply for grants. There is a lot of grant money available currently, and a lot of discussion about what MPFC does and how we fit into certain roles. We have had conversations about how we may be missing out on opportunities, we can't really have much staff capacity at our current level. Kalamazoo Nature Center has graciously had staff involved, with Stephanie as Administrator at a discounted rate, and served a fiduciary role for the Council, but they are local organization and we're a statewide organization along with having statewide partners who need a nonprofit collaborator in fire in Michigan, but there aren’t many organizations who are well positioned to operate at a statewide level when talking about fire. In many states, TNC is able to do that, but that isn’t the case in Michigan. One organization that would be a potential option is Tall Timbers Research Institute. If we're interested in pursuing that possibility, we’d want to have idea of what that might look like from an administrative and operational side. The Coalition of Prescribed Fire Councils also hopes to be available as a 501c3 fiduciary organization for any State councils, with a lot going on behind the scenes now to make this happen, with the potential able to be serve as that umbrella organization. More time will be dedicated to this topic in June.

Jeb Barzen added that Wisconsin prescribed Fire Council is a 501C3 which has MOU's with the Department of Natural Resources and with the Forest Service and with the NRCS, and have Forest Service grants through The Nature Conservancy in Wisconsin as sub-grantees.

Strategic Plan – Tribal Acknowledgement

We’ve adopted our strategic plan but acknowledged that we still had work to be done when it comes to the various tribes across the state, which would take time to be done right and format an item that they all can agree upon. With the busy spring burn season and TREX for many of us, capacity has been limited and there hasn’t been much movement here since our last meeting.

DNR Certified Burn Manager Program Update
Michigan DNR has created their fire specialist position who will also serve as a member of the Council, along with being tasked of overseeing the certified burn manager program. Jeff Corser was selected, but will need to cover some other positions until they can back fill them, but he looks forward to attending in the near future.

(Update as of 5/22/24 – Position is currently vacant again and was reposted, with application window already closed.)

 

Partner Updates

Weather Update

Nathan Jeruzal with NWS Grand Rapids explained that the fire weather partner agency coordination meeting was held a couple weeks ago with all the state and federal agencies in lower Michigan and one of the things that came out from that people should be aware of is that red flag warning criteria is going to be adjusted for lower Michigan. The temperature criteria will be taken out of the criteria, which was suggested by the Forest Service and agreed upon.

The availability of weekly fire weather briefings outside of fire agencies were discussed as they are recognized as valuable tools for those who are able to access them. Nathan would need to make sure they follow all laws and regulations but would look into options to try and get it to others, as briefings are sent out after those meeting. Another agency may be able to distribute after it is out of NWS’s hands.

 Michigan Grassland Coalition

Jarod explained that Pheasants Forever and the DNR are spearheading the Michigan Grassland coalition, which once was the Michigan Pheasant Initiative. A lot of discussion about grassland management and burning, with capacity issues being identified as a major problem. Local chapters of Pheasants Forever interested in conducting their own burns and wanting/needing trainings may be an avenue to bring new partners into the mix.

 

Future Meetings

June 11th (11am-2pm) – Jay’s in Gaylord with virtual option

Sept 10th (11am-2pm) – Upper Peninsula – TBD with virtual option

Dec 10th (11am – 2pm) – Edward Lowe Foundation in Cassopolis with virtual option

9.5.23 Quarterly MPFC Council Meeting Notes

Quarterly Michigan Prescribed Fire Council Steering Committee Meeting
September 5th, 2023
11am – 2pm ET
Hybrid (Teams + in person @ Escanaba Bio Innovation Center)



Welcome and Introductions Bruce Miller TNC, Steve Woods - Huron Pines, Dave Borneman – private contractor, Amy Frye USDA-NRCS, Jarod Reibel – Ed Lowe Foundation, Mark Sargent, Glenn Palmgren, Zach Parmentier Hiawatha USFS, Mike Smalligan, Vic Bogosian Pokagon Band of Potawatomi NR, Craig Maier, Megan Hoffman MDNR Huron Pines Americorp member FRD, Eric Britzike USFS, Jack McGowan-Stinski LSFC, Nathan Holoubeck - WPFC, Todd Aschenbach – GVSU, Michele Richards - MIANG Fort Custer

General Updates

·         NE-MW Regional Rx Fire Science and Management Workshop in Madison, WI: Aug 29-31, 2023

MI PFC did a $500 sponsorship to get our name out to the guests and support the collaboration efforts.

Amazing event, lots of connections, Tribal centered. 33 states attended. Lots of great talk about a whole variety of things fire. Networking was super helpful. Steve discussed with George Jensen and Zach regarding administration of MPFC and there are two different answers. Zach said we should talk about it. See if there’s a chance for some alignment. The idea of a non-profit associated with the Fire Council, people thought it was a good idea to give us access to funding and have continuity over time. The perfect solution was not yet found. Forest service is looking to treat 50 million acres in the next ten years, but they need partnerships. Cultural use of fire was a huge takeaway. How much recent science and studies have been going on to figure out fire history in the east. Hiawatha and Ottawa doing a lot with that with agreements with Tribal Communities up the in the UP. USFS can’t do this alone, it has to be a team effort. Planning team looking for suggestions on what to change or keep.

·         Administrative rates update:

o   Currently pay $60/hour for admin work. Newly proposed $30/hr for up to 10 hours a month is the short-term fix for reducing the cost of our administration. Will reassess in one year August 2024.

·         Upcoming MPFC leadership opportunity:

o   In February Jarod Reibel will be the chair, and we will be looking for a new vice chair. Planting seeds for finding new candidates for the Vice Chair position.

o    

·         Forest to MI Faucet project:

o   MI DNR is acquiring a grant to show the impacts of forests on drinking water quality. Perhaps we can work together on this project. It’s focused on water quality, but opportunities to explore fire as a land management tool is providing water protection as well as ecological integrity. $50,000 over three years for training and talking about prescribed fire and its positive impact on forests and water. Private lands focus. Federal dollars through forest stewardship program. Trainings to increase prescribed fire on private lands. Negotiating with NFWF for funds. Contract with MPFC starting in October 1 for three years, related to training and technical assistance to private landowners. Mike Smalligan needs match. Use of fire foam, fire breaks, lots of overlap with water issues. MIARNG has match. This can cover admin costs, too. Federal funding hitch, this is a congressional earmark. She’s trying to save Lake Erie. Can only use south of the 43rd parallel. Emphasis on this region, southern half of lower peninsula. It would be valuable for MPFC to have a synthesis of the research between prescribed fire and water quality. Mike has other projects in northern MI. USFS is exploring the connection between wildfire versus prescribed fire and its impacts on water quality. Maximum fire return intervals of 15 down to 6 years, tied to cultural burning materials at the conference. Bay Mills and Sioux Tribes among others. They’ve done an adaptive fire management plan with Tribal members. Many medicinal plants that live in the peat and pine island ecosystems that were fire adapted.

o   Jessica Miesel might give us a primer on research and where to start on this topic. Jack says there’s a synthesis of the fire history research forthcoming.

o   Vic down in Pokagon land that has a consultant with a minor botany celebrity. Not a plant that he doesn’t know. Fall burns, Native Americans burned everywhere they could as often as they could. Pre-European presence, forest biomass was 50% reduced. Most of our southern forests are now not only mesic, but increases water runoff instead of aquifer research.

o   Strategic plan will talk more about human health, a note about pfas foam and firefighter safety.



Updates from Subcommittees

·         Burning Issues 2024 Planning Updates (Jarod Reibel)

o   Moving it to FCTC, Feb 6&7, save the date out in a week or so. Integrating with KNC Damien Panek as Terry Todd speaker on 8 Feb.

o   Keep it at same price as last year, $90, with discounts for students and potentially others.

o   Some of our topics will overlap with NE-MW Workshop, but that’s not a bad thing. Cultural Burning (Ferin from NEMW), Objectives and Outcomes, Canadian wildfire smoke, fire and wildlife (bats and herps), and invasive species case studies. Brainstormed potential speakers and starting outreach to those folks.

·         Strategic Planning Updates (Mark Sargent)

o   Had three meetings via web-conference. Evaluated last strategic plan. Brainstormed new ideas and concepts. Feel it’s ready for review. Used a jam board to help develop different ideas and concerns from the group. Then we did live editing.

o   Not sure of what process to gather input from other folks. Moderate sized group or send it out to all the membership.

o   Group reviewed briefly all together during meeting.

o   Creating a culture of prescribed fire strikes a chord – the resurgent focus on Tribal lands. Replace creating with restoring. Distinction between cultural burning and prescribed fire (under vision). ...continue a culture of prescribed fire and embrace cultural burning knowledge...

o   Values – add environmental to ecological in second bullet

o   Do we want to consider that it’s not just beneficial but essential to meet our long-term ecological needs.

o   Comments and input would be incorporated in November, and in December present a final document for approval and adoption, then February present to the entire MPFC at the annual meeting.


Present update of Strat plan to steering committee                                                                           Sept 5th

Send proposed strat plan to all member for review and input                                                        Sept/Oct

Bird Hunting Season                                                                                                                                        Sept/Oct

Edit proposed strat plan                                                                                                                                Nov

Present final proposed strat plan to steering committee/or subset                                              Dec 5th

Present Strat plan to all members                                                                                                              Feb 2024

Click button to view in new window or download, send comments to Mark Sargent

o   Curious about the sub-committee(s) for safety and research? Or two new subcommittees? If those tasks might be functions of the existing committees or something. explanation of need and purpose would help. Do we have the willpower and strength to broaden that given the level of effort we currently count on. Maybe safety ends up being a function of training and quals. Fire Science Consortia does the research portion – is there a different function we would serve? Do a synthesis ourselves? Having a forum for discussing research?

·         Training and/or TREX Updates (Steve Woods/John Taylor/Michele Richards)

o   Training side – one of the important parts of facilitating TREX and all training is to have clarity in who does what and participates on what. MOA fully drafted. The idea says that we all agree training is important to support prescribed fire and we agree to collaborate to increase the amount of training. Provides people cover who field questions about whether or not their agency supports their time to serve as cadre or send students to training. Defines what responsibilities, minimum training standards, etc.

o   TREX had a couple of planning calls, Michele and Steve discussing with TEA. Cleared the air on some things and moving in a good direction. They heard us that it was necessary for us to have continuity with their staff participation, and we are filling some of those issues with having Steve manage some of the networking responsibilities.

o   Three 130/190 trainings in northern Michigan in the next two years will be offered via Huron Pines. Mt. Pleasant, Traverse City, and either Cheboygan or Alpena. First one would be in the first week of April.

o   Fire collaborative has an MOU circulating, initial review Sag-Chip Tribe, Headwaters Collaborative and GTLC. Once signed by enough participants they will build mobile fire cache for use by signatories.

o   Huron Pines hosting a workshop for peer-to-peer learning on fire in the jack pine ecosystem. Multiple agency partners participating. Van tour. Should start to set in motion of doing a TREX in northern lower in two years.

o   Huron Pines asked their invasive species lead to host a workshop with all the other CISMA coordinators in MI focused on using fire for invasive species control. Hungry for something besides spraying chemicals all the time. Lots of talk about integrated management but not a lot of using those tools. Hopefully involving an invasive species burn. Jack can provide old PPTs and other docs for this topic.

·         Education/Outreach Updates (Leadership role vacant)

o   Vacant at the moment. If interested in leading or ideas for outreach contact info@firecouncil.org

Partner Updates:

·         WI Prescribed Fire Council (Nathan Holoubek representing)

o   Forest Service and TNC grants will allow them to hire a program specialist to hire staff to take on aspirations. Working on training and prescribed fire/burn boss certification duties. Potentially looking at a very part time executive director, too.

o   MOU signed with NRCS

 

·         Tallgrass and Oak Savanna Fire Science Consortium

o   HANDS-ON FIRE SCIENCE METHODS WORKHOP April 7-12, 2024 round three of these workshops can be found here: http://www.tposfirescience.org/fire-sci-methods-workshop

Financial Report (Amy on behalf of Stephanie)

Project summary of funds spent from White Oak Initiative. Grant completed but $720.00 paid ahead for admin time to work on a S-130/S-190 Field day training in Spring 2024 (on deferred revenue contract at KNC).

$14,455.11 current MPFC bank account balance.

Do we start offering more training to increase revenue/use grant funds? More discount rates for students to widen reach/work towards accessibility opportunities?

Upcoming Events

  • MPFC Annual Meeting and Burning Issues Workshop in Feb 2024, stay tuned for registration and details coming in next few months.

  • Kalamazoo Nature Center “Rekindling” Fire exhibit still open to public until May 2024

Open Floor

Someday have a place to put all our burns in a map. MDNR has some opening for federal data. Not sure if that going to be something that will be robust yet. Work is ongoing with this. Glenn will update as progress is made.

Conclusion

Next Quarterly Meeting will be:
Tuesday, December 5th, 2023
Ed Lowe in Cassopolis, MI